Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutC- 2 Review of Cost Study and REcommendatons to StaffAGENDA ITEM HONORABLE MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL MEMBERS ALAN KREIMEIER, DIRECTOR OF ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES/ CFO M. DELACH, CITY MANAGER * TE: JUNE 28, 2010 REVIEW OF COST STUDY AND RECOMMENDATIONS TO STAFF is recommended that Council review the materials, information and comments presented during e workshop and provide direction to staff with respect to any changes in the proposed fee schedule. )n January 19, 2010, the City Council approved a PSA with Revenue Cost Specialists. The City has een using the cost allocation prepared by Revenue Cost Specialists (RCS) in 2001 as a basis to pdate the budget annually. By having RCS update the prior plan, this will allow an external and bjective method for the internal charges to enterprise and special revenue funds. The City's user -es have been increased based on the Consumer Price Index. 7e consultant held a series of meetings with department representatives to initially review cost location, and then developed a fee study update for the City of Azusa which is attached to this 1. Executive Summary 2. Summary of Revenues, Costs and Subsidies. 3. Fee Comparison Report. a FINAL ®RAFT Fee Study Update forthe City of Azusa MAY 2010 Prepared by: Revenue & Cost Specialists, LLC 1519 East Chapman Ave, Suite C Fullerton, CA 92831 www.revenuecost.com (7.14)992-9020 Copyright, 2010 by Revenue & Cost Specialists EXECUTIVE SUMMARY By acceptance of Revenue & Cost Specialists' (RCS) proposal, the City of Azusa decided to subject its fee-based services to detailed analysis dedicated toward seeking alternate, and more equitable, ways to finance City services provided to the community. Due to the various demands made of the City, it is essential that the City Council and management have complete information upon which to assess fees charged to the public for services provided. The table at the end of this Executive Summary lists each service reviewed in this study. It indicates that the City could realize approximately $591,000 in additional new revenue if the recommendations provide herein are adopted and implemented. Organization of Report. This Executive Summary explains RCS's philosophy concerning fee- based services and cost analysis with a discussion of Costs Generally Defined. The report then lists the Types of Costs included in our analysis, our General Recommendations, and closes with a Conclusion. COSTS GENERALLY DEFINED The basic costs of operating any business are direct labor and employee benefits, direct materials, allied indirect costs, overhead costs, and fixed asset or "depreciation" charges. Determination of "Costs". After the passage of Proposition 13, the California Taxpayers Association, the California Chamber of Commerce, the National Tax Limitation Committee and the California Association of Realtors put Proposition 4 before the voters. It was adopted by 74.3% of the voters of California on November 6, 1979, and became effective on July 1, 1980, retroactive to Fiscal Year 1978-79. This proposition, which became Article XIIIB of the State Constitution, addressed all city revenues and established a limit on the growth of tax revenues. Also, because of Proposition 4, fee services cannot exceed the "costs reasonably borne" by the City in providing the service. If the fee exceeds the cost, the excess fee is defined to be a special tax, which Proposition 13 requires be approved by two-thirds of the voters. As Article XII1B was written by the above business groups, it is not surprising that they recommended a business -oriented approach to the costs of govermnental services. For example: "The phrase 'costs reasonably borne by such entity in providing the regulation, product, or service' is intended to incorporate all appropriations by an entity for reasonable costs appropriate for the continuation of the service over time. This City of Azusa Fee Study Update includes ongoing expenses such as operation costs and a reasonable allocation for overhead and administration, but it also includes reasonable allocation for start-up costs and future capacity. Thus, reasonable allocations for capital replacement, expansion of services, and repayment of related bond issuances would be considered 'costs reasonably borne'." Principle Involved. A basic principle involved in this Report is the recognition of those full business costs as they are as defined by the authors of the Constitutional amendment, NOT just those costs which 1) the City might recognize and decide to budget; or 2) which it might decide to use in some other cost analysis methodology; or 3) that other jurisdictions not so complying might use; or 4) that some accounting or other consulting firm might decide it should use, based on some external, non -California legal requirements. These cost elements have been determined in a businesslike manner per basic business principles, and applied to each and every fee -financed or fee -financeable service provided by the City, modified only slightly to accotmnodate the published intent and definitions of the authors of Article XIIIB. Thus a logical, legal, and Colistitutionally-mandated cost-consciousness can now be applied to City operations. TYPES OF COSTS Salaries and Wages. City govermnent is in fact a service industry, therefore it is natural that salaries make up the largest single element of cost in most services. Employee Fringe Benefits. Since the annual time of an employee has been fully allocated to service centers, fringe benefit costs also must be included. These costs are current operating expenses and are included in the City's Annual Budget. Fringe benefit costs were taken into consideration by salaried personnel employed by the City. Maintenance and Operation Costs All maintenance and operation costs, including non -personnel expenses such as professional services, insurance, operating supplies, etc„ were derived from the 1 "Summary of Proposed Implementing Legislation and Drafter's Intent with Regard to Article XIIIB of the California Constitution (Proposition 4, November 6, 1979)'; Spirit of 13, Inc.; 1980; Califomia Chamber of Commerce; page 6. 2 City of Azusa Fee Study Update 2009-2010 Council -approved budget and allocated via percentages or through actual allocation to each of the service centers identified in a department or division. Overhead Costs. Although overhead is a well established and necessary expense item in business, it is ottly recently that governments started adopting business techniques. As many believe that govenmtent is no different than a good corporation -- the axiom "Buy good management" should prevail in government "corporations." RCS utilizes three types of overhead, which are discussed below in turn. General City Overhead - would be for the general administration of the City, such as the functions for City Council, City Manager, City Clerk, City Attorney, Human Resources, and Finance. Each service is very important to the smooth futiodorrng of the City. But, their primary function is to support other departments and not to provide an end-user service to the public. Departmental and/or Divisional Overhead - is usually allocated to the department head, the departmental secretary or the division managers. Again, the purpose of these services is to insure the smooth functioning of the department and not to provide an end-user service to the public. Unallocated Operating Costs - are the costs for any service that could have been accounted for in an Internal Service Fund (ISF) such as information systems, building maintenance costs, and vehicle maintenance costs. Each of these services could be purchased from the private sector. RCS calculated general overhead and unallocated operating costs overhead through our Cost Allocation Process. Our analysis identified departments receiving each type of overhead service, selected a method for allocating the costs to those departments, and then reviewed the allocations for reasonableness. Costs associated to the each department were included as well as a uniquely determined departmental overhead rate. c City of Azusa Fee Studd Update GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS Adoption of Modifications to Current Fee Structure It is recommended that the City Council adjust the fee schedule for the enumerated City services presented in Appendix A of this Report. Continued use of the "full business costing" concept will create consistency in the establislunent of fees, and allow for timely adjustment to reflect changes in the cost of providing services. Review of Suggested Recovery Rates The City Council should review each service and the suggested recovery race to much of each service should be recovered through feedetermine how s, and how much should be subsidized through the City's tax dollars. This review is very important because it gives City staff direction as to what the Council wants to subsidize and what it does not. All Things To All People While the City is deciding who to subsidize and what to finance, it should remember it cannot provide all things to all people. It should therefore prioritize what it hopes to accomplish. If the Council decides to provide more subsidies today, it is doing so at the expense of other services which can only be financed by tax dollars, such as Police Patrol services, Street Maintenance, and other public services. Therefore the Council must decide which direction it wants to proceed in, fully aware of the consequences of either action. CONCLUSION If all the recommendations and suggestions made in this Report are adopted, the City's financial picture would be improved. Also, far more equity between taxpayers and fee -payers, as well as fairness between property -related and non property -related services could be secured, assisting in the City's continued financial stability into the future. The following Schedule 1 portrays the various services assessed during our analysis. Appendix A _ Detailed Worksheets The substance of RCS's work effort on this project is primarily comprised of two different worksheets shown in the detail of this report (see Appendix A). The first, "Revenue and Cost Summary Worksheet" is on the left hand side. These worksheets include a description of the service, the current fee structure, the recommended recovery rate, and other pertinent. information. Also included is the revenue and cost comparison and suggestions for fee modifications. .! Citv of Azusa Fee Study Update Presented on the facing page, titled "Cost Detail Worksheet", is the worksheet which details the costs involved with each service. This page identifies those employees providing the service, the time spent, and their related costs. CITY OF AZUSA SUMMARY OF REVENUES, COSTS, AND SUBSIDIES FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF # SERVICE TITLEPROFIT/ REVENUE PERCENT RECOVERY S-001 ZONING CLEARANCE COST SUBSIDY CURRENT SUGGEST S-002 MINOR DESIGN REVIEW $6,272 $4,871 $1,401 128.8% 100.0% S-003 STAFF LEVEL DESIGN REVIEW $1,800 $5,817 ($4,017) . 100.0% S-004` MAJOR DESIGN REVIEW $12'878 $27 988 ,,) ($15109 0% 46 46.0% 100.0% S-005 USE PERMIT $6.100 $11,402 ($5,302). 53.5% 100.0% S -005A MINOR USE PERMIT $25,530 $26,109 ($579) 97.0% 100.0% S-006 USE PERMIT MODIFICATION $$3,400 $7,124 $3,276 146.0% 100.0% S-007 PRELIMINARY PLAN REVIEW $ $4,065 ($213) 94.8% 100.0% S-008 MINOR VARIANCE $237 $237 $1,355 ($1,118) 17.5% 100.0% S-009 VARIANCE $1 .,476 $1,640 ($164) 90.0% 100.0% S-010 ZONE CHANGE $17,536 $16,413 $1,123 106.8% 100.0% S-011 DEVELOPMENT CODE AMENDMENT $5,000 $4,913 $87 101:8% 100.0% S-012 DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT $5,000 $4,913 $87 101,8% 100.0% S-013 GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT $8,100 $8,762 ($662) 99.4% 100.0% S-014 SPECIFIC PLAN $10,200 $12,848 ($2,648) 100.0% 5-015 SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENT $8,200 $4,423 ($1,223) 879.4%T0% 87.0% 100.0% S-016 TENTATIVE PARCEL MAP $4,000 $4,458 ($458) 89.7% 100.0% S-017 TENTATIVE TRACT MAP $2,050 $5,735 ($3,685) 35,7% 100.0% S-018 REVERSION TO ACREAGE $18,632 $30,454 ($11.822) 61.2-% 100.0% S-019 LOT MERGER $1336 , $1,954 ($618) 68.4% 100.0% S-020 ENVIRON. CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION REV. $502 $4,134 $1,257 ($755) 39.9% 100.0% S-021 ENVIRON INITIAL STUDY/NEGATIVE DEC. $2,070 $7,713 ($3,579) 53.6% 100.0% S-023 ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT REVIEW $7,357 ($5,287) 28.1% 100.0% S-024 MITIGATION MONITORING $ $21,415 ($12,415) 42.0% 100.0% S-025 ANNEXATION $289 $289 $1'286 ($997) 22.5% 100.0% S-026 CONDOMINIUM CONVERSION REVIEW $5,300 $8,059 ($ 78.4% 100.0% S-027 MINOR SIGN REVIEW $5,124 $4,640 $484 $484 110.7% 100.0% S-028 MAJOR SIGN REVIEW $2,183 $ $$18 135.9% 100.0% S-029 ZONING LETTER $958 $958 $940 $940 $18 101.9% 100.0% S-030 TEMPORARY OCCUPANCY REVIEW $2,580 $3,417 ($837) 75.5% 100.0% S-031 TEMPORARY USE PERMIT $420 $476 ($56) 88.2% 100.0% S-032CONTINUANCE PROCESSING $5'137 $4.891 $246 105.0% 100.0% $544 $465 $79 117.0% 100.0% Page 1 of 6 SCHEDULEI POSSIBLE NEW $4,000 $15,100 $5,300 $600 ($3,300) $200 $0 $200 ($1,100) $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $3,700 $6,300 $0 $0 $3,600 $5,300 $0 $1,000 $0 # $0 # ($600) $0 $0 $100 ($200) $0 # -- - - - -- - - - - _ - - - - - - - - SCHEDULE 1, -.- SUMMARY - SUMMARY OF REVENUES, COSTS, AND SUBSIDIES FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 Page 2 of 6 POSSIBLE PROFIT/ PERCENT RECOVERY NEW REF # SERVICE TITLE REVENUE COST (SUBSIDY) CURRENT SUGGEST REVENUE S-033 STAFF TIME EXTENSION REVIEW $367 $321 $46 114.3% 100.0% $0 S-034 COMMISSION TIME EXTENSION REVIEW $1,088 $1,429 ($341) 76.1% 100.0% $300 S-035 APPEAL TO PLANNING COMMISSION $478 $1,592 ($1,114) 30.0% 100.0% $0 # S-036 APPEAL TO CITY COUNCIL $1,452 $5,055 ($3,603) 28.7% 100.0% $0 # S-037 CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE $927 $1,085 ($158) 85.4% 100,0% $0 # S-038 STREET NAME PROCESSING W/O MAP $916 $1,086 ($170) 84.3% 100.0% $0 # S-039 STREET RE -NAME PROCESSING $1,561 $1,497 $64 104.3% 100.0% $0 # S-040 BUILDING ADDRESS PROCESSING W/O MAP $319 $621 ($302) 51.4% 100.0% $0 # S-041 BUILDING RE -ADDRESS PROCESSING $449 $364 $85 123.4% 100.0% $0 # S -041A COM DEV NEWSPAPER PUBLICATION $0 $3,225 ($3,225) 0.0% 100.0% $3,200 S-042 GENERAL PLAN MAINTENANCE $64,647 $100,005 ($35,358) 64.6% 50.0% $0 S-043 BUILDING PLAN CHEMINSPECTION $646,473 $768,484 ($122,011) 84.1% 100.0% $122,000 S -043A BUILDING DEMOLITION PERMIT $8,880 $9,518 ($638) 93.3% 100.0% $600 S-044 SPECIAL BUILDING INSPECTION $5,667 $11,288 ($5,621) 50.2% 100.0% $5,600 S-045 GRADING PLAN CHECK $455 $11,727 ($11,272) 3.9% 100.0% $11,300 S-046 GRADING INSPECTION $910 $16,325 ($15,415) 5.6% 100.0% $15.400 S-047 PUBLIC/PRIVATE IMPROVEMENT PLAN CHK $5,000 $9,454 ($4,454) 52.9% 100.0% $4,500 S-048 - PUBLIC/PRIVATE IMPROVEMENT INSPECT. $5,000 $39,043 ($34,043) 12.8% 100.0% $34,000 S-049 FINAL PARCEL MAP - $777 $1,061 ($284) 73.2% 100.0% $300 S-050 FINAL TRACT MAP $8,526 $25.045 ($16,519), 34.0% 100.0% $3,200 S-051 EASEMENT CHECK $702 $587 $115 119.6% 100.0% $0 # S-052 MONUMENT INSPECTION $207 $204 $3 101.5% 100.0% $0 # S-053 BOND PROCESSING $73 $83 ($10) 88.0% 100.0% $0 # S-054 TAX CLEARANCE PROCESSING $172 $115 $57 149.6% 100-0% $0 # S-055 LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT $2,102 $2,412 ($310) 87.1% 100.0% $300 S-056 STREET/R-O-W ABANDONMENT PROC. $2,614 $3,814 ($1,200) 68.5% 100.0% $1,200 S -056A SUSMP PLAN REVIEW $0 $3,203 ($3,203) 0.0% 100.0% $3,200 S -056B SWPPP PLAN REVIEW $0 $2,982 ($2,982) 0.0% 100.0% $3,000 S -056C HYDROLOGY/TRAFFIC/SOILS REPORT REV. $0 $5,963 ($5,963) 0.0% 100.0% $6,000 S -056D DRAINAGE PLAN REVIEW $0 $3,826 ($3,826) 0.0% 100.0% $3.800 S-057 SIDEWALK/CURB/GUTTER ENCROACH PER. $1,216 $3,142 ($1,926) 38.7% 100.0% $1,900 S -057A DRIVE APPR/STREET CUT ENCROACH PER. $9,852 $26,220 ($16,368) 37.6% 1000% $16,400 Page 2 of 6 CITY OF AZUSA SCHEDULEI SUMMARY OF REVENUES, COSTS, AND SUBSIDIES FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 POSSIBLE REF R SERVICE TITLE REVENUE PROFIT/ PERCENT RECOVERY NEW S -U58 OBSTRUCTION PERMIT COST SUBSIDY CURRENT SUGGEST REVENUE 5-059 WIDE, OVERWEIGHT, OVERLONG LOAD REV $1,300 $4,607 $1,66278.2% ($362) 0 100.0 /° $400 S-060 HOUSE MOVING PERMIT $22,523 ($17,916) 20.5% 100.0% $0 S -060A INDUSTRIAL. WASTE PERMIT $2 $938 ($707) 24.6% 100.0% $0 S-0608 FATS, OILS, AND GREASE PROGRAM $0 $0 $0 $6,156 ($6,156) 0.0% 100.0% $6,200 S-061 SEWER SADDLE INSTALLATION REVIEW $3 ($32,681) 0.0% 100.0% $32,7$0 S -061A REVISIONS TO APPROVED PLANS $2 $ $291 1 290 ($48) 83.5% 100.0% $ S-0618 EXTRA PLAN CHECK/INSPECTION $0 $0 $2,649 ($2,649) 0.0% 100.0% $0 S-062 BLUEPRINT/MAP COPY SERVICE N/A N/A N/A N/A 100.0% $0 S-063 REAL PROPERTY RECORDS REPORT/INSP. $1,900 $25,945 $2,078 ($178) 91.4% 100.0% $200 S-064 RESIDENTIAL RENTAL HOUSING REG/INSP $31.135 ($5,190) 83.3% 100.0% $5,200 S-065 LIEN RELEASE $52,274 $96,822 ($44.548) 54.0% 100.0% $44,500 S-066 ADMIN. HEARING APPEAL $13,000 $16,498 ($3,498) 78.8% 100.0% $3,500 S -066A PUBLIC NUISANCE ADMIN HEARING $300 $1,258 ($958) 23.8% 100.0% $1,000 S-0668 COST RECOVERY HEARING $2,475 $10.776 ($8,301) 23.0% 100.0% $8,300 S -066C CODE ENFORCEMENT FINES $413 $1,335 ($922) 30.9% 100.0% $900 N/A N/A N/A N/A 100.0% $0 SUBTOTAL -DEVELOPMENT SERVICES $1,061,359 $1,541,347 ($479,988) 68.9% $377,900 S-067 NOISE DISTURBANCE RESPONSE $0 S-068 POLICE FALSE ALARM RESPONSE $30,000 $212,020 ($212,020) 0.0% 100.0% $0 S -068A ALARM REGISTRATION $68.394 ($38,394) 43.9% 100.0% $0 S-069 DUI ACCIDENT RESPONSE/INVESTIGATION $6,752 $8,145 ($1,393) 0 82.9 /° 0 100.0% $0 S-070 VEHICLE EQUIPMENT CORRECTION INSP. $0 ($9,996) 0.0% 100.0% $0 S-071 VIN VERIFICATION $ 10,996 $1 ($2.734) 75.0% 100.0% $0 S-072 POLICE SPECIAL SERVICES $705 $100 $826 $826 ($126) 84.7% 100.0% $100 S -072A BOOKING SERVICES $109 $125 ($16) 87.2% 100.0% $0 S-073 ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT $0 $249,860 ($249,860) 0.0% 100.0% $25,000 S-074 DANCE PERMIT $2,000 $4,675 ($2,675) 42.8% 100.0% $2,700 S -074A PAWN SHOP PERMIT $480 $544 ($64) 88.2% 100.0% $100 S -074B MASSAGE PARLOR PERMIT $40 $1,375 ($1,335) 2.9% 100.0% $0 4 S -074C CARNIVAL WORKER PERMIT $0 $505 ($505) 0.0% 100.0% $0 4 $0 $139 ($139) 0.0% 100.0% $0 4 Page 3 of 6 -- -- ----- --. ..--- -- - -- -- ---- - .. .. .-- - - - -----. .. _- SCHEDULE L_--- ^-ITOF4ZbS ^ SUMMARY OF REVENUES, COSTS, AND SUBSIDIES FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 POSSIBLE Page 4 of 6 PROFIT/ PERCENT RECOVERY NEW REF # SERVICE TITLE REVENUE COST (SUBSIDY) CURRENT SUGGEST REVENUE S-075 IMPOUNDED VEHICLE RELEASE $37.500 $82,967 ($45,467) 45.2% 100.0% $45,500 - S-076 REPOSSESSED VEHICLE RELEASE $600 $516 $84 116.3% 100.0% $0 S-077 RECORDS CHECK/CLEARANCE LETTER $12,000 $12,525 ($525) 95.8% 100.0% $500 S-078 IMMIGRATION LETTER $12,000 $12,525 ($525) 95.8% 100.0% $500 S-081 POLICE PHOTO REPRODUCTION $1,276 $551 $725 231.6% 100.0% ($700) S-082 VIDEO/AUDIO TAPE REPRODUCTION $1,650 $2,240 ($590) 73.7% 100.0% $600 S-083 POLICE REPORT COPY $1,500 $19,365 ($17,865) 7.7% 100.0% $0 S-084 SPECIAL COMPUTER SEARCH $81 $86 ($5) 94.2% 100.0.% $0 S-085 CIVIL SUBPEONA PROCESSING $3,000 $3,287 ($287) 91.3% 100.0% $0 S-086 DUCES TECUM SUBPEONA PROCESSING $15 $76 ($61) 19.7% 100.0% $0 S-087 ANIMAL CONTROL $50,500 $239,340 ($188,840) 21.1% 100.0% $0 SUBTOTAL -PUBLIC SAFETY SERVICES $168,408 $941,021 ($772,613) 17.9% $74,300 S-088 ADULT SPORTS $71,175 $138,015 ($66,840) 51.6% 50.0% N/A S-089 YOUTH SPORTS/AFTER SCHOOL PLAYGRND $132.396 $569,570 ($437,174) 23.2% 35.0% N/A [� S-090 CONTRACT RECREATION CLASSES $7,350 $87,586 ($80,236) 8-4'% 55:0°/x- t S-091 AQUATICS PROGRAMS $97,000 $390,660 ($293,660) 24.8% 25.0% N/A S-092 SUMMER DAY CAMP $65,625 $176,964 ($111,339) 37.1% 50.0% N/A S-094 BALLFIELD RENTAL $32,500 $29.036 $3,464 111.9% 100.0% N/A S-095 PARKIPICNIC SHELTER RESERVATION $15,000 $27,036 ($12,036) 55.5% 100.0% N/A S-096 RECREATION CENTER RENTAL $32,500 $32,456 $44 100.1% 100.0% N/A S-097 INTER -LIBRARY LOAN PROCESSING $572 $7,193 ($6,621) 8.0% 10.0% $100 S-098 BOOK RESERVATION $52 $2,700 ($2,648) 1.9% 4.0% $100 S-099 LOST LIBRARY CARD PROCESSING $2,000 $888 $1,112 225.2% 100.0% ($800) S-100 OVERDUE LIBRARY MATERIAL PROCESSING $12,000 $14,877 ($2,877) 80.7% 100.0% $500 S-101 LOST/DAMAGE LIBRARY MATERIAL PROC. $8,500 $52,207 ($43,707) 16.3% 25.0% $4,200 S-102 PASSPORT APPLICATION $38,750 $58,528 ($19,778) 66.2% 100.0% $0 S-103 LIBRARY DVD RENTAL $5,850 $5,421 $429 107.9% 100.0% $0 S-104 RENTAL OF LIBRARY AUDITORIUM $1,700 $10,264 ($8,564) 16.6% 100.0% $0 " S -104A LIBRARY PUBLIC COPY SERVICE $2,500 $7,000 ($4,500) 35.7% 100.0% $1,500 S-1048 LIBRARY FAX SERVICE $0 $174 ($174) 0.0% 100.0% 1 $0 " Page 4 of 6 CITY OF AZUSA SCHEDULEI SUMMARY OF REVENUES, COSTS, AND, SUBSIDIES FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 Page 5 of 6 POSSIBLE REF # SERVICE TITLE REVENUE COST PROFIT/ PERCENT RECOVERY NEW SUBSIDY CURRENT SUGGEST REVENUE SUBTOTAL -LEISURE & CULTURAL SERVICES $525,470 $1,610,575 ($1,085,105) 32.6% $5,600 S-105 S-106 NEW UTILITY ACCOUNT SET-UP $264,050 $293,877 ($29,827) 89.9% 100.0% $14,600 UTILITY DELINQUENT TURN OFF/ON $211,300 $242.263 ($30,963) 87.2% 100.0% $0 S-107 THEFT OF WATER/LIGHT INVESTIGATION $2,856 $2,443 $413 S-108 WATER PRESSURE TEST $0 $3,954 116.9% 100.0% $0 5-109 WATER METER TEST $4,000 $4,985 ($3,954) ($985) 0.0% 80.2% 100.0% $0 "* ** S-110 S-111 WATER QUALITY TEST $3,270 $3,744 ($474) 87.3% 100.0% 100.0% $0 $500 S-112 FLOW TEST TEMPORARY METER RENTAL SERVICE $21,960 $16,511 $5,449 ° 133.0% ° 100.0% ($5,400) S-113 NEW WATER METER INSTALLATION $3,600 $8,899 ($5,299) 40,5% 100.0% $2,200 S-114 NEW WATER SERVICE INSTALLATION $8,136 $100,000 $7,202 $934 113.0% 100.0% ($900) S-115 NEW BACKFLOW DEVICE INSPECTION REV. $119,088 ($19,088) 84.0% 100.0% $0 S-116 ANNUAL BACKFLOW DEVICE INSP. REVIEW $20,130 $147,600 $18,614 $1,516 108.1% 100.0% ($1,500) S-118 SEWER BLOCKAGE CHECK $25,000 $92,052 $55,548 160.3% 100.0% ($55,500) S-119 SEWER DYE TEST $27,716 ($2,716) 90.2% 100.0% $0 S-120 EMERGENCY SEWAGE SPILL RESPONSE $2.000 $6,500 $1,155 $845 173.2% 100.0% ($800) S-122 ELECTRIC METER TEST $6,929 ($429) 93.8% 100.0% $0 S-123 TOTAL ELECTRIC SERVICE RE -INSTALL $0 $3,823 ($3,823) 0.0% 100.0% $0 "* S-124 ADDITIONAL ELECTRIC SPAN INSTALL $12,312 $3,078 $17,758 $4,341 ($5,446) 69.3% 100.0% $5,400 S-125 TEMPORARY ELECTRIC INSTALLATION $8,208 $11,838 ($1,263), 70.9% 100.0% $1,300 S-126 TEMP SINGLE PHASE TRANSFORMER INSTL ($3,630) 69.3% 100.0% $3,6$0 S-127 TEMP THREE PHASE TRANSFORMER INSTL $24 $4,200 .000 $$4,200 ($200) 99.2% 100.0% $0 S-128 ELECTRIC LINE EXTENSION/UPGRADE $120,000 $4,557 ($357) 92.2% 100.0% $0 S-130 BANNER INSTALLATION $123,777 ($3.777) 96.9% 100.0% $0 S-131 AFTER HOURS STANDBY/CALL OUT $11,160 $100,000 $13.892 ($2,732) 80.3% 100.0% $2,700 5-132 SWEEPING $118,826 ($18,826) 84.2% 100.0% $0 .STREET $0 $203,732 ($203,732) 0.0% 100.0% $203,700 SUBTOTAL- UTILITY & MAINTENANCE SERVICES $1,103,360 $1,376,176 ($272,816) 80.2% $169,900 S-133 NEW BUSINESS REGULATION $78,899 $74,1570 $4,742 106./0 4 0 100.0/° ($4,700) Page 5 of 6 _- - -- - -- -- __ _ -- SCHEDULE -1 - SUMMARY OF REVENUES, COSTS, AND SUBSIDIES FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 KEY TO SYMBOLS: " - Market Sensitive # - Occurs Infrequently Page 6 of 6 POSSIBLE PROFIT/ PERCENT RECOVERY NEW REF # SERVICE TITLE REVENUE COST (SUBSIDY) CURRENT SUGGEST REVENUE S-134 HOME OCCUPATION PERMIT $5,808 $7,695 ($1,887) 75.5% 100.0% $1,900 S-135 NEW TAXUTOW TRUCK PERMIT $590 $525 $65 112.4% 100.0% $0 S-136 MASSAGE PARLOR TECHNICIAN PERMIT $776 $829 ($53) 93.6% 100.0% $100 S-137 BUSINESS REGULATION RENEWAL $133,776 $78,852 $54,924 169.7% 100.0% ($54,900) S-138 BUSINESS LICENSE DUPLICATE/AMEND $432 $464 ($32) 93.1% 100.0% $0 S-139 BUSINESS LICENSE LIST COPY $352 $606 ($254) 58.1% 100.0% $300 S-140 SOLICITOR PERMIT $158 $171 ($13) 92.4% 100.0% $0 S-142 BINGO PERMIT ANNUAL REVIEW $400 $586 ($186) 68.3% 100.0% $200 S-143 FIREWORKS STAND PERMIT $5,263 $6,218 ($955) 84.6% 100.0% $1,000 S -143A FILM PERMIT $0 $1,421 ($1,421) 0.0% 100.0% $0 S-144 RETURNED CHECK PROCESSING $22,175 $54,400 ($32,225) 40.8% 100.0% $20,400 S-145 RE -ISSUANCE OF LOST CHECK $1,992 $1,425 $567 139.8% 100.0% ($600) S-146 DOCUMENT REPRODUCTION $0 $444 ($444) 0.0% 100.0% $0 S-147 DOCUMENT CERTIFICATION $1,728 $1,338 $390 129.1% 100.0% ($400) S-148 TAPE/DVD COPY SERVICE $12 $49 ($37) 24.5% 100.0% $0 S-149 CANDIDATE PROCESSING $250 $2,899 ($2,649) 8.6% 100.0% $0 S -149A INITIATIVE PROCESSING $0 $676 ($676) 0.0% 100.0% $0 S-150 NOTARY SERVICE $2,000 $2,872 ($872) 69.6% 100.0% $0 SUBTOTAL -ADMINISTRATION SERVICES $254,611 $235,627 $18,984 108.1% ($36,700) GRAND TOTAL $3,113,208 $5,704,746 ($2,591,538) 54.6% $591,000 KEY TO SYMBOLS: " - Market Sensitive # - Occurs Infrequently Page 6 of 6 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-001 TITLE: ZONING CLEARANCE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $56 per application $45 per application REF #: S-002 TITLE: MINOR DESIGN REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $360 per application $1,165 per application REF #: S-003 TITLE: STAFF LEVEL DESIGN REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $1,431 per application $3,110 per application Modification to an Existing Structure - S350 per application REF #: S-004 TITLE: MAJOR DESIGN REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $6,100 deposit $10,000 deposit with charges at the fully allocated hourly rates of all personnel involved plus any outside costs. REF #: S-005 TITLE: USE PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $4,255 per application S4,350 per application REF #: S -005A TITLE: MINOR USE PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE 51,040 per application $715 per application 1 - May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-006 TITLE: USE PERMIT MODIFICATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $1,926 per application - Modification to Major CUP $2,035 per application - Modification to Major CUP $455 per application - Modification to Minor CUP 5510 per application - Modification to Minor CUP REF #: S-007 TITLE: PRELIMINARY PLAN REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE 5237 per application $1,355 per meeting 50% of the fee for the first meeting would be applied against future Planning/Engineering fees for that project. Fees for all subsequent meetings would not have fees credited. REF #: S-008 TITLE: MINOR VARIANCE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $738 per application $820 per application REF #: S-009 TITLE: VARIANCE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $4,384 per application $4,105 per application Single Family Structure - $850 per application Single Family Structure - $940 per application REF #: S-010 TITLE: ZONE CHANGE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $5,000 deposit $5,000 deposit with charges at the fully allocated hourly rate for all personnel involved plus any outside costs. REF #: S-011 TITLE: DEVELOPMENT CODE AMENDMENT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE S5,000 deposit $5,000 deposit with charges at the fully allocated hourly rate for all personnel involved plus any outside costs. .May 18, 201( 2 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-012 TITLE: DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT CURRENTFEE 21-50 lots - $3,717 RECOMMENDED FEE 58,,100 deposit 51-100 - $10,310 - S10,000 deposit with charges at the fully allocated hourly rate for Annual monitoring - $4,000 deposit all personnel involved, plus any outside costs. Annual monitoring - $5,000 deposit with charges at the fully allocated hourly rate for all personnel involved plus any outside costs. REF #: S-013 TITLE: GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $10,200 deposit $15,000 deposit with charges at the fully allocated hourly rate for all personnel involved, plus any outside costs. REF #: S-014 TITLE: SPECIFIC PLAN CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $8,200 deposit $10,000 deposit with charges at the fully allocated hourly rate for all personnel involved, plus any outside costs. REF #: S-015 TITLE: SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $4,000 deposit 55,000 deposit with charges at the fully allocated hourly rate for all personnel involved plus any outside costs. REF #: S-016 TITLE: TENTATIVE PARCEL MAP CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $2,050 per application $5,735 per application REF #: S-017 TITLE: TENTATIVE TRACT MAP CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE 5-20 lots - $3,066 5-20 lots - S6,210 21-50 lots - $3,717 21-50 lots - $7,455 51-100 - $5,189 51-100 - $10,310 101+ lots - $6,660 101+ lots - $11,590 3 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-018 TITLE: REVERSION TO ACREAGE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $1,336 per application $1,955 per application plus consultant fee REF #: S-019 TITLE: LOT MERGER CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $502 per application $1,255 per application plus consultant fee REF #: S-020 TITLE: ENVIRON. CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION REV. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $106 per application $200 per application REF #: S-021 TITLE: ENVIRON INITIAL STUDYINEGATIVE DEC. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $1,035 per application $3,680 per application or deposit determined by staff with . charges at the fully allocated hourly rates for all personnel - involved plus any outside costs. REF #: S-023 TITLE: ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $4,500 deposit $10.000 deposit with charges at the fully allocated hourly rates for all personnel involved, plus any outside costs. REF #: S-024 TITLE: MITIGATION MONITORING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE ' 5289 per study plus $85 per hour Deposit determined by staff with charges at the fully allocated hourly rates for all personnel involved, plus any outside costs. May 18, 201( 4 i CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-025 TITLE: ANNEXATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE 56,300 deposit Deposit determined by staff with charges at the fully allocated hourly rates for all personnel involved, plus any outside costs, REF #: S-026 TITLE: CONDOMINIUM CONVERSION REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $5,124 per application $4,640 per application plus consultant fee REF #: S-027 TITLE: MINOR SIGN REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE S59 per application $45 per application REF #: S-028 TITLE: MAJOR SIGN REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $479 per application $470 per application REF #: S-029 TITLE: ZONING LETTER CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Charge actual time and materials Single Family Residential - $125 per application Other - $285 per application REF #: S-030 TITLE: TEMPORARY OCCUPANCY REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $420 per application $475 per application 5 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-031 TITLE: TEMPORARY USE PERMIT RECOMMENDEDFEE IURRENTFEE 467 per application $445 per application 5% discount for Azusa -based non-profit organizations 25% discount for Azusa -based non-profit organizations REF #: S-032 TITLE: CONTINUANCE PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $544 per application $465 per application REF #: S-033 TITLE: STAFF TIME EXTENSION REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $367 per application $320 per application REF #: S-034 TITLE: COMMISSION TIME EXTENSION REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $544 per application $715 per application REF #: S-035 TITLE: APPEAL TO PLANNING COMMISSION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $478 per application $1,590 per application REF #: S-036 TITLE: APPEAL TO CITY COUNCIL l^ CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE v` $726 per application $2,530 per application May 18, 201( 6 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-037 TITLE: CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEOFEE $927 per application _ $1,085 per application REF #: S-038 TITLE: STREET NAME PROCESSING W/O MAP CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE S916 per application $1,085 per application REF #: S-039 TITLE: STREET RE -NAME PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $1,561 per application $1,495 per application REF #: S-040 TITLE: BUILDING ADDRESS PROCESSING W/O MAP CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $319 per application $620 per application REF #: S-041 TITLE: BUILDING RE -ADDRESS PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE 5449 per application $365 per application REF #: S -041A TITLE: COM DEV NEWSPAPER PUBLICATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None 5215 per notice 7 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 I REF #: S-042 TITLE: GENERAL PLAN MAINTENANCE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE I 10% surcharge on Building permits No Change REF #: S-043 TITLE: BUILDING PLAN CHECK/INSPECTION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Fees are based on valuation tables Increase Permit and Pian check fees 20% to recover 100% of the costs. plus: • Optical Records Surcharge - S12 per permit Permit Automation Surcharge - $24 per permit REF #: S -043A TITLE: 'BUILDING DEMOLITION PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $185 per permit Permit: 0-150 Sq Ft - S55 • 151-5,000 Sq Ft -$110 - 5,001-50,000 Sq Ft - $220 50,001-250,000 Sq Ft- $330 250,001+ Sq Ft - $445 Plan Check - B5% of the Permit Fee plus permit issuance and permit surcharges REF #: S-044 TITLE: SPECIAL BUILDING INSPECTION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $55.56 per hour (2 hour minimum) $110 per hour (2 hour minimum) plus permit issuance and permit surcharges REF #: S-045 TITLE: GRADING PLAN CHECK i CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE 50% of Grading Permit Fee <100 CY - $865 100-1000 CY - $865 plus S14 per 100 CY 1,000-10,000 CY - S991 plus S74 per 1,000 CY 10,000-50,000 CY - S1,657 plus $17 per 1.000 CY 50,000+ CY - $2,337 plus S231 per 10,000 CY Precise Plan - $535 per sheet May 18, 2010 I I I 8 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-046 TITLE: GRADING INSPECTION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $130 per permit <100 CY - S345 100-1000 CY - $345 plus $48 per 100 CY 1,000-10,000 CY - $777 plus $72 per 1,000 CY 10,000-50,000 CY - 51,425 plus $87 per 1,000 CY 50,000+ CY - $4,905 plus $570 per 10,000 CY REF #: S-047 TITLE: PUBLIC/PRIVATE IMPROVEMENT PLAN CHK CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE 2.5% of the estimated construction cost $0-$100,000 - 3% of the estimated construction cost next $400.000 - 2.5% of the estimated construction cost amounts over $500,000 - Deposit of 2% of the estimated construction cost REF #: S-048 TITLE: PUBLIC/PRIVATE IMPROVEMENT INSPECT. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE 2.5% of the estimated construction cost S04100,000 - 5% of the estimated construction cost next S400,000 - 3.5% of the estimated construction cost amounts over $500,000 - Deposit of 2% of the estimated construction cost REF #: S-049 TITLE: FINAL PARCEL MAP CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE City Fee - $777 per map $1,060 per map plus consultant fee Consultant Fee - $700 per map REF #: S-050 TITLE: FINAL TRACT MAP CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFE 1-5 lots: City - $963 Consultant - $710 5-10 lots - $1,685 6-10 lots: City - $1,001 Consultant -$915 11-25 lots - $2,665 11-25 lots: City - 57,079 Consultant - $1,350 26-50 lots - $3.510 26-50 lots: City - $1,234 Consultant - $2,200 51-100 lots - $5,390 51-100 lots: City -$1,434 Consultant -$3,300 101-150 lots -S6,160 lDl-150 lots: City -$1,743 Consultant -55,000 151 + lots - $7,440 151+ lots: City - S2,035 Consultant - S6,600 plus consultant fees 9 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-051 TITLE: EASEMENT CHECK CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Tract Maps: - Tract Maps - $295 City - $351 Parcel Maps - $295 Consultant - $210 Parcel Maps: plus consultant fees City - $346 - Consultant - $175 REF #: S-052 TITLE: MONUMENT INSPECTION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE City - $207 per monument $205 per monument plus consultant fees Consultant - $125 per monument REF #: S-053 TITLE: BOND PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE City - $73 per application $85 per application plus consultant fees Consultant - $75 per application REF #: S-054 TITLE: TAX CLEARANCE PROCESSING, CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE City - $172 per application $115 per application plus consultant fees Consultant - $625 per application REF #: S-055 TITLE: LOT LINE ADJUSTMENT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $1,051 per application $1,205 per application plus consultant fee REF #: S-056 TITLE: STREETIR-O-W ABANDONMENT PROC. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $1,307 per application $2,000 deposit vdth charges at the fully allocated hourly rates toi all personnel involved plus any outside costs May 18, 201( 10 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S -056A TITLE: SUSMP PLAN REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None $1,600 per application REF #: S -056B TITLE: SWPPP PLAN REVIEW CURRENTFEE - RECOMMENDED FEE None $1,490 per application REF #: S -056C TITLE: HYDROLOGY/TRAFFIC/SOILS REPORT REV. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None $1,500 deposit per report with charges at the fully allocated - hourly rate for all personnel involved, plus any outside costs. REF #: S -056D TITLE: DRAINAGE PLAN REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None $04100,000 - 3% of the estimated construction cost next $400,000 - 2.5% of the estimated construction cost amounts over $500,000 - Deposit of 2% of the estimated construction cost REF #: S-057 TITLE: SIDEWALK/CURB/GUTTER ENCROACH PER. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE Up to 75 Linear Feet - $183 Up to 75 Linear Feet - S475 Each Additional 75 Linear Feet - $59 Each Additional 75 Linear Feet - $155 REF #: S -057A TITLE: DRIVE APPR/STREET CUT ENCROACH PER. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Up to 100 Square Feet - $183 Up to 100 Square Feet - $475 Each Additional 100 Square Feet - $59 Each Additional 100 Square Feet - $205 11 May 18, 2010 l CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-058 TITLE: OBSTRUCTION PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $65 per permit $85 per permit REF #: S-059 TITLE: WIDE, OVERWEIGHT, OVERLONG LOAD REV CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE Single Trip - $17 No Change as fees are set by the Slate. Annual Permit - $94 Fees are set by the State REF #: S-060 TITLE: HOUSE MOVING PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $231 per permit $940 per permit REF #: S -060A TITLE: INDUSTRIAL WASTE PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None New/Modification - $620 per permit Annual - $205 per permit REF #: S -060B TITLE: FATS, OILS, AND GREASE PROGRAM CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None New - $410 per permit Annual - $155 per permit REF #: S-061 TITLE: SEWER SADDLE INSTALLATION REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE 5243 per review $290 per review . May 18, 2010 12 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S -061A TITLE: REVISIONS TO APPROVED PLANS CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None - Charge the fully allocated hourly rate for all personnel involved plus any outside costs. REF #: S -061B TITLE: EXTRA PLAN CHECKIINSPECTION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None Charge the actual costs for any extra plan reviews or inspections. REF #: S-062 TITLE: BLUEPRINT/MAP COPY SERVICE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $19 per sheet $20 per sheet or actual outside costs REF #: S-063 TITLE: REAL PROPERTY RECORDS REPORT/INSP. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE CondotTownhouse-$30 Condorrownhouse-$50 Vacant/Unimproved Land - $143 - Vacant/Unimproved Land - S160 Single Family Dwelling - S143 Single Family Dwelling - $160 Multi -Family Dwelling - $143 per parcel + $8 per unit _ Multi -Family Dwelling - S160 per parcel + $10 per unit Commercial - $143 Commercial - $160 REF #: S-064 TITLE: RESIDENTIAL RENTAL HOUSING REG/INSP CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $54 per parcel plus $8 for each additional unit $105 per parcel plus S7 for each additional unit Reinspection - $85 per inspection REF #: S-065 TITLE: LIEN RELEASE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $65 per release Substandard - $100 per release Admin Fine - $80 per release 13 'May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-066 TITLE: ADMIN. HEARING APPEAL ' IS60 per appeal $250 per appeal REF #: S -066A TITLE: PUBLIC NUISANCE ADMIN HEARING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE i $75 per hearing, which is refunded if the appelant prevails. $325 per hearing, which is refunded is the appelant prevails i REF #: S -066B TITLE: COST RECOVERY HEARING j CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $37.50 per hearing, which is refunded is the appelant prevails $120 per hearing, which is refunded is the appelant prevails REF #: S -066C TITLE: CODE ENFORCEMENT FINES CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE First Offense - $50 First Offense - $100 Second Offense - $250 Second Offense - $250 Third Offense - $500 Third Offense - $500 REF #: S-067 TITLE: NOISE DISTURBANCE RESPONSE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE First and Second Response - No Charge First and Second Response - No Charge Third Response - Full Costs of all responding personnel Third Response - Full Costs of all responding personnel May 18, 2010 14 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-068 TITLE: POLICE FALSE ALARM RESPONSE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Registered Alarm: No Change First response in a year - No Charge Second Response - $50 Third Repsonse - S250 Fourth and subsequent Responses - $500 Unregistered Alarm: First response in a year - No Charge Second Response - S50 Third Repsonse - $250 Fourth and subsequent Responses - increases incrementally by S250 REF #: S -068A TITLE: ALARM REGISTRATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE New -$25 New -$25 Renewal - $16 Renewal - $16 REF #: S-069 TITLE: DUI ACCIDENT RESPONSEll NVESTIGATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $1,160 per accident Charge the fully allocated hourly rate for all emergency personnel responding, not to exceed $12,000 per incident by Slate Law. REF #: S-070 TITLE: VEHICLE EQUIPMENT CORRECTION INSP. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Citation issued by Azusa Police - No Charge Citation issued by Azusa Police - No Charge Citation issued by other Agencies - $15 per vehicle Citation issued by other Agencies - $10 per vehicle REF #: S-071 TITLE: VIN VERIFICATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $35 per vehicle $40 per vehicle 15 May 18, 2010 l CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-072 TITLE: POLICE SPECIAL SERVICES CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Officer - $109 per hour Officer - $125 per hour Reserve Officer - $35 per hour. Reserve Officer - $35 per hour REF #: S -072A TITLE: BOOKING SERVICES CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE None -- $125 per booking REF #: S-073 TITLE: ENTERTAINMENT PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Temporary - $250 per application Temporary - $275 per application Regular - $250 per application Regular- $1,100 per application Renewal - $250 per application Renewal - $1,100 per application REF #: S-074 TITLE: DANCE PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE One Time - $40 per application - One Time - $45 per application Annual - $40 per application Annual - $45 per application REF #: S -074A TITLE: PAWN SHOP PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $40 per application $1.375 per application REF #: S -074B TITLE: MASSAGE PARLOR PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE None $505 per application May 18, 201( 16 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S -074C TITLE: CARNIVAL WORKER PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE None $140 per application REF #: S-075 TITLE: IMPOUNDED VEHICLE RELEASE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $75 per vehicle Standard Release - $150 per vehicle DUI Release - $205 per release REF #: S-076 TITLE: REPOSSESSED VEHICLE RELEASE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $15 per vehicle $15 per vehicle REF #: S-077 TITLE: RECORDS CHECK/CLEARANCE LETTER CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $24 per letter $25 per letter REF #: S-078 TITLE: IMMIGRATION LETTER CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE - S24 per letter $25 per letter REF #: S-081 TITLE: POLICE PHOTO REPRODUCTION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $58 plus cost of photos S25 plus cost of photos Photo CD Reproduction - $5-$10 Photo CD Reproduction - $5-S10 17 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-086 TITLE: DUCES TECUM SUBPEONA PROCESSING CURRENTFEE - RECOMMENDED FEE $15 per request plus reproduction costs No Change Fees are set by State Law. May 18, 2010 18 REF #: S-082 TITLE: VIDEOIAUDIO TAPE REPRODUCTION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE S75 per tapelCDlDVD Dispatch Tape - $110 per tape Other Tape - $85 per tape Digital Copy- $85 This fee should only be charged if the request is not a Public . Records request. REF #: S-083 TITLE: POLICE REPORT COPY CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE As this service is covered by the Public Records Act, the fee As this service is covered by the Public Records Act, the fee should match the City's copy charge fee: should match the City's copy charge fee: $0.56 - 1st page $0.60 - 1st page $0.15 - each additional page S0.20 - each additional page $1 minimum $1 minimum REF #: S-084 TITLE: SPECIAL COMPUTER SEARCH CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE S81 per hour $86 per hour REF #: S-085 TITLE: CIVIL SUBPEONA PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $20 plus reproduction costs No Change $150 per day deposit plus travel costs REF #: S-086 TITLE: DUCES TECUM SUBPEONA PROCESSING CURRENTFEE - RECOMMENDED FEE $15 per request plus reproduction costs No Change Fees are set by State Law. May 18, 2010 18 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: 5-087 TITLE: ANIMAL CONTROL CURRENTFEE Dog License: 1 year license Regular- S40 Neutered - S20 3 year license Regular - $120 Neutered - $60 Senior/Low Income - Free Lifetime with Implanted Microchip - $155 Duplicate - $10 Late Payment Fee - 50% of License Fee Voluntary Cat License: 3 year $35 Lifetime with Implanted Microchip $55 RECOMMENDEDFEE Dog License: 1 year license Regular - $80 Neutered - $20 3 year license Regular - $240 Neutered - $60 Senior/Low Income - Free Lifetime with Implanted Microchip - $155 Duplicate - S10 Late Payment Fee - 50% of License Fee Voluntary Cat License: 3 year S35 Lifetime with Implanted Microchip $55 REF #: S-088 TITLE: ADULT SPORTS CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE Adult Co-ed Volleyball - $175 per team This program is recovering 70.3% of it Direct Program costs. Men's Basketball - $325 per team The Council -set Direct Cost Recovery Goal for this program is Adult Softball - $350 per team 50%. - Adult Baseball - $400 per team Golf Tournament- $100 per golfer REF #: S-089 TITLE: YOUTH SPORTS/AFTER SCHOOL PLAYGRND CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE Various Sport Activities - $25-$65 per participant This program is recovering 34.7% of it Direct Program costs. The Council -set Direct Cost Recovery' Goal for this program is Examples are: 35%. Pony Baseball - S65 ($60 for additional family members) Winter Pony Baseball - $40 ($35 for additional family members) Mighty Mite Baseball - $40 ($35 for additional family members) Mighty Mite Basketball - $40 ($35 for additional family members) REF #: S-090 TITLE: CONTRACT RECREATION CLASSES CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE The instructor receives 75% of the class fee and the City This program is recovering 61.4% of it Direct Program costs. receives the remaining 25%. The Council -set Direct Cost Recovery Goal for this program is 55%. 19 May 18, 2010 0 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-096 TITLE: RECREATION CENTER RENTAL CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Various rates depending on the room rented, time of day, and The City should charge what the market will bear for rental of residency status. City facilities. May 18, 2010 20 REF #: S-091 TITLE: AQUATICS PROGRAMS URRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE ec Swim: $0.50 - Children under 13 $2 - Teens $2 - Adults This program is recovering 36.2% of it Direct Program costs. 1 - Seniors The Council -set Direct Cost Recovery Goal for this program is Instructional Swim Lessons - $30 $40 - 40 minute lessons 25%. Private Lessons - $30 unior Lifeguard Class - $80 j. vdm Team - 850 ($45 for additional family members) Pool Rental - S350-$550 per hour depending on the people i rant for Maintenance Services - S36,130 -i REF #: S-092 TITLE: SUMMER DAY CAMP CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $18 per child per day ($16 per day for 2nd family member) This program is recovering 50.6% of it Direct Program costs. The Council -set Direct Cost Recovery Goal for this program is Registration Fee - $20 (one-time) 50%. Field Trip Registration - Various fees to recover the costs of the event Grant for Maintenance Services - $12,000 REF #: S-094 TITLE: BALLFIELD RENTAL CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Various fees depending on the field and services requested. Each group that uses the City's fields should be charged the full costs of their usage. i REF #: S-095 TITLE: PARK/PICNIC SHELTER RESERVATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Various fees depending on the location No Change REF #: S-096 TITLE: RECREATION CENTER RENTAL CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Various rates depending on the room rented, time of day, and The City should charge what the market will bear for rental of residency status. City facilities. May 18, 2010 20 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-097 TITLE: INTER -LIBRARY LOAN PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE S1.50 per item plus postage if needed. S2 per item plus postage if needed. REF #: S-098 TITLE: BOOK RESERVATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $0.25 per item S0.50 per item REF #: S-099 TITLE: LOST LIBRARY CARD PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $5 per card $3 per card REF #: S-100 TITLE: OVERDUE LIBRARY MATERIAL PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Adult - $0.20 per item per day Adult - $0.25 per item per day Child - $0.10 per item per day - Child - $D.10 per item per day REF #: S-101 TITLE: LOST/DAMAGE LIBRARY MATERIAL PROC. CURRENTFEE - RECOMMENDED FEE $10 plus the cost of the item $15 plus the cost of the item REF #: S-102 TITLE: PASSPORT APPLICATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $25 per application No Change Fee should increase when the Federal Government increases the fee. 21 May 18, 2010 i I CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-103 TITLE: LIBRARY DVD RENTAL (CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE ,i 1.50 per item (for 2 days) No Change REF #: S-104 TITLE: RENTAL OF LIBRARY AUDITORIUM URRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE 20 per hour - For Profit during business hours (3 hour min.) $25 per hour - For Profit during business hours (3 hour min.) �+20 per hour - For Profit outside business hours (3 hour min.) $25 per hour - For Profit outside business hours (3 hour min.) 615 per hour -Non-Profit during business hours (3 hour min.) $15 per hour -Non-Profit during business hours (3 hour min.) Nanable per hour- Non-Profit outside business hours (3 hour Variable per hour- Non-Profit outside business hours (3 hour _ Mia) min.) - o Charge -Resident, Non-Profit, and Government No Charge -Resident, Non-Profit, and Government REF #: S-104A TITLE: LIBRARY PUBLIC COPY SERVICE i URRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Black & White Copies - $0.15 per copy Black & White Copies - $0.20 per copy - Color Copies - $0.25 per copy Color Copies - $0.50 per copy REF #: S-104B TITLE: LIBRARY FAX SERVICE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None Domestic-$1 per page International - $4 for the first page plus $1 for each additional page REF #: S-105 TITLE: NEW UTILITY ACCOUNT SET-UP $42 per account Same Day Connection (7:00-3:00) - $35 Same Day Connection (3:00-5:30) - S119 Positive Identification Check - $1.25 a S45 per account Same Day Connection (7:00-3:00) - $35 Same Day Connection (3:00-5:30) - $85 Positive Identification Check - $1.25 22 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-106 TITLE: UTILITY DELINQUENT TURN OFF/ON CURRENTFEE - RECOMMENDED FEE Delinquent Tum -on: Delinquent Turn -on: 7 am -3 pm - S35 7 am -3 pm - $35 3 pm -5:30 pm - S119 3 pm -5:30 pm - $85 Fri -Sat 7 am -8 pm - S119 Fri -Sat 7 am -8 pm - $205 Industrial/Unusual - $119 Industrial/Unusual - $290 Late Payment Penalty - $7.50 or 5% of total outstanding balance, Late Payment Penalty - $7.50 or 5% of total outstanding balance, whichever is greater whichever is greater REF #: S-107 TITLE: THEFT OF WATER/LIGHT INVESTIGATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE If it shown that an individual has used water or electricity without If it shown that an individual has used water or electricity without paying for it, then that person should be charged the full costof paying for it, then that person should be charged the full cost of the investigation and damages and triple the cost of the the investigation and damages and triple the cost of the estimated usage. estimated usage. $238 Minimum $250 Minimum REF #: S-108 TITLE: WATER PRESSURE TEST CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE 1 free test per calendar year - 1 free test per calendar year $61 per test - each subsequent test, refunded if there is a system $165 per test - each subsequent test, refunded if there is a problem. system problem. REF #: S-109 TITLE: WATER METER TEST CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE Charge time and materials if the meter is running properly. Charge the Fully Allocated Hourly Rates plus any outside costs if the meter is running properly. REF #: S-110 TITLE: WATER QUALITY TEST CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $109 per test plus lab costs $125 per test plus lab costs 23 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-111 TITLE: FLOW TEST CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $366 per test $275 per test REF #: S-112 TITLE: TEMPORARY METER RENTAL SERVICE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $100 per meter plus 51.000 deposit $130 per meter plus $1,000 deposit REF #: S-113 TITLE: NEW WATER METER INSTALLATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $226 plus actual materials costs $200 plus actual materials costs REF #: S-114 TITLE: NEW WATER SERVICE INSTALLATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE 3/4"-1" - $2,558 deposit 3/4"-l"- $3,000 deposit 2" - S3,047 deposit 2" - $3,200 deposit 3" - $6,823 deposit 3" - $6,823 deposit 4" - S7,432 deposit 4" - $7,432 deposit 6" - S9,382 deposit 6" - $9,382 deposit REF #: S-115 TITLE: NEW BACKFLOW DEVICE INSPECTION REV. CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $366 per device $340 per device REF #: S-116 TITLE: ANNUAL BACKFLOW DEVICE INSP. REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $123 per device $80 per device s May 18, 2010 24 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-118 TITLE: SEWER BLOCKAGE CHECK CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Charge the Fully Allocated Hourly Rates for all personnel used, Charge the Fully Allocated Hourly Rates for all personnel used, with a $354 minimum. with a $500 minimum. If blockage is due to City trees, then no charge. If blockage is due to City trees, then no charge. REF #: S-119 TITLE: SEWER DYE TEST CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $200 per test $115 per test REF #: S-120 TITLE: EMERGENCY SEWAGE SPILL RESPONSE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Charge the fully allocated hourly rates for all responding Charge the fully allocated hourly rates for all responding personnel personnel REF #: S-122 TITLE: ELECTRIC METER TEST CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE One free test per calendar year. One free test per calendar year. Residental -.$182, refunded if the meter is running fast Residental - $160, refunded if the meter is running fast Commercial - $348, refunded if the meter is running fast Commercial - $370, refunded if the meter is running fast Industrial - $513, refunded if the meter is running fast Industrial - S440, refunded if the meter is running fast REF #: S-123 TITLE: TOTAL ELECTRIC SERVICE RE -INSTALL CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $513 per service plus materials $740 per service plus materials REF #: S-124 TITLE: ADDITIONAL ELECTRIC SPAN INSTALL CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $513 per installation plus materials $725 per installation plus materials 25 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-125 TITLE: TEMPORARY ELECTRIC INSTALLATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $513 per installation plus materials for overhead or underground $740 per installation plus materials for overhead or underground REF #: S-126 TITLE: TEMP SINGLE PHASE TRANSFORMER INSTIL CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE Charge the fully allocated hourly rates for all personnel involved, No Change plus materials with a $3,098 minimum. REF #: S-127 TITLE: TEMP THREE PHASE TRANSFORMER INSTL CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Charge the fully allocated hourly rates for all personnel involved, No Change plus materials with a $6,200 minimum. REF #: S428 TITLE: ELECTRIC LINE EXTENSION/UPGRADE CURRENT FEE RECOMMENDED FEE Charge the fully allocated hourly rates for all personnel involved, No Change plus materials. REF #: S-130 TITLE: BANNER INSTALLATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $465 per banner $580 per banner REF #: S-131 TITLE: AFTER HOURS STANDBY/CALL OUT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Charge the actual time and materials with a 2 hour minimum. Charge the fully allocated hourly rates for all responding personnel with a 2 hour minimum May 18, 201( 26 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT ". FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 rt V ,e REF #: S-132 TITLE: STREET SWEEPING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None The cost of this service can be recovered through a Prop. 218 assessment district or as a surcharge on the refuse bill. REF #: S-133 TITLE: NEW BUSINESS REGULATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE Outside Contractor - $71 RegulationlCollect Information/Collect Tax=Total Reinstate Outside Contractor - $71 Rental Business - $71 Outside Contractor - $0/$251$26.82 = $51.82 All Others - $148 Reinstate Outside Contractor - SO/$12.88/$26.82 = $39.70 Rental Business - S0/S25/$13.94 = $51.82 Partial Payment of Fees - $15 additional charge All Others - 543.49/594.711$32.88 = S :71.08 Partial Payment of Fees - $15 additional charge REF #: S-134 TITLE: HOME OCCUPATION PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FE S66 per permit $85 per permit REF #: SA 35 TITLE: NEW TAXI/TOW TRUCK PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $590 per application $525 per application REF #: 5-136 TITLE: MASSAGE PARLOR TECHNICIAN PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $194 per application $205 per application 27 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-137 TITLE: BUSINESS REGULATION RENEWAL CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $36 - application fee $21 - application fee $59 - Field Collection fee on delinquent accounts $26 - Field Collection fee on delinquent accounts Partial Payment of Fees - $15 additional charge Partial Payment of Fees - $15 additional charge REF #: S-138 TITLE: BUSINESS LICENSE DUPLICATEIAMEND CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $12 per license $13 per license REF #: S-139 TITLE: BUSINESS LICENSE LIST COPY CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $11 per list $20 per list REF #: S-140 TITLE: SOLICITOR PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $53 plus $35 for each individual permit S57 plus $38 for each individual permit REF #: S-142 TITLE: BINGO PERMIT ANNUAL REVIEW CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE S200 per review $295 per review REF #: S-143 TITLE: FIREWORKS STAND PERMIT CURRENTFEE - RECOMMENDEDFEE $277 per application S325 per application - r I May 1 S, 2011 28 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S -143A TITLE: FILM PERMIT CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $1,227 per day (25% discount for Azusa -based nonprofit No Change organizations) REF #: S-144 TITLE, RFTt1RNFn CWrr-- ( oonr`Ccernic CURRENTFEE. RECOMMENDED FEE $25 per NSF Check for first check $48 per NSF Check S35 per NSF Check for each check thereafter REF #: S-145 TITLE: RE -ISSUANCE OF LOST CHECK CURRENTFEE S83 per check REF #: S-146 TITLE: DOCUME CURRENTFEE $0.56 - 1st page $0.15 - each additional page No charge if the report is 4 pages or less Certain documents specified in the Government Code - $0.10 per page Documents on a CD - $10 RECOMMENDED FEE S60 per check NT REPRODUCTION RECOMMENDED FEE $0.60 - 1st page $0.20 - each additional page No charge if the report is 4 pages or less Certain documents specified in the Government Code - $0.10 perpage Documents on a CD - $5 REF #: S-147 TITLE: DOCUMENT CERTIFICATION CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $36 per request $30 per request REF #: S-148 TITLE: TAPEIDVD COPY SERVICE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEOFEE S3 per tape Tape - $12 per tape DVD - $14 per disk 29 May 18, 2010 CITY OF AZUSA FEE COMPARISON REPORT FISCAL YEAR 2009-2010 REF #: S-149 TITLE: CANDIDATE PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE $25 per application No Change Fee is set by State Law REF #: S -149A TITLE: INITIATIVE PROCESSING CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDED FEE None $200 per initiative Fee is set by State Law REF #: S-150 TITLE: NOTARY SERVICE CURRENTFEE RECOMMENDEDFEE $10 per signature No Change Fee is set by State Law r May 18, 2010 30